The Conejo Valley's Italian restaurant scene runs from white tablecloth trattorias to casual pizzerias, and it keeps growing. Sette Sorelle ("Seven Sisters") opened January 21, 2026 in the former Selvin's Restaurant space at the Palm Garden Hotel in Newbury Park, serving pastas, pinsas and other specialties, and joins long-running favorites like Tuscany il Ristorante, open since 1987. If you are new to the area or weighing neighborhoods like North Ranch, this guide covers the restaurants worth knowing and what homes near them have been selling for. For context, the median sale price in Thousand Oaks was $1.0M in March 2026, down 16.3% from a year earlier, according to Redfin.

Key Takeaways

  • As of March 2026, the Thousand Oaks median sale price was $1.0M, down 16.3% year over year, while Westlake Village was $1.6M, up 26.7%.
  • Sette Sorelle opened January 21, 2026 at Palm Garden Hotel in Newbury Park, joining established restaurants like Tuscany il Ristorante operating since 1987.
  • Top rated Italian restaurants include Tuscany il Ristorante, Nonna, BASTA, Casa Nostra, and Made in Italy Bistro across Westlake Village and Thousand Oaks.
  • Westlake Village homes have been selling in about 45 days over the trailing 12 months per Zillow, faster than the 55 day national average.
  • Made in Italy Bistro and Buca di Beppo are the value picks; Tuscany il Ristorante and Casa Nostra are the upscale end.
Quick Answer

The best Italian restaurants in the Conejo Valley cluster in Westlake Village, Thousand Oaks, and Newbury Park, including Tuscany il Ristorante (since 1987), Nonna, BASTA, Casa Nostra, and Sette Sorelle, which opened January 21, 2026 at Newbury Park's Palm Garden Hotel. Made in Italy Bistro and Buca di Beppo offer casual, lower priced options.

Where can I find the best Italian restaurants in Conejo Valley?

The most acclaimed Italian restaurants cluster around three key areas: Westlake Village, Thousand Oaks' dining districts, and Newbury Park. The names that come up most often in local reviews are Tuscany il Ristorante, Nonna, BASTA, Made in Italy Bistro, Casa Nostra Ristorante and Marcello Ristorante. For upscale dining, Tuscany il Ristorante at 968 S Westlake Blvd. #4 in Westlake Village serves traditional dishes like pumpkin ravioli and linguini with fresh clams in a polished setting, with a long list of nightly specials. Nonna, at 951 S Westlake Blvd. #102 in Westlake Village, is the more relaxed option and a short drive from anywhere in the city. It averages 4.6 stars on Google, and reviewers single out the servers for knowing the menu cold. Near Janss Marketplace, Buca di Beppo Thousand Oaks is located at 205 N. Moorpark Road and offers family-style Italian dining.

Median Home Prices in Italian Restaurant Neighborhoods

$0 $500K $1.0M $1.5M $1.0M $1.6M $749K Thousand Oaks Westlake Village Downtown TO

Source: Redfin, Zillow data, March 2026

What are current home prices in Thousand Oaks' Italian dining neighborhoods?

The three dining hubs sit at noticeably different price points. In March 2026 the median sale price in Thousand Oaks was $1.0M, down 16.3% from a year earlier, and the median price per square foot was $539, down 2.3%, according to Redfin. Westlake Village, home to Tuscany il Ristorante and Nonna, had a median sale price of $1.6M that month, up 26.7% year over year. A swing that size in a small market usually says more about which homes happened to close than about underlying values. By April 2026 the median list price in Thousand Oaks was $1.04M, roughly 10% below April 2025, and by one affordability estimate that price calls for around $193K in household income. Over a longer window the picture is steadier: Westlake Village's median sale price over the trailing 12 months was $1,700,000, up 13%, and homes sold after about 45 days on market versus a national average of 55, according to Zillow.

Neighborhood Median Home Price Price/Sq Ft Days on Market Notable Italian Restaurants
Westlake Village $1.6M $600 58 days Tuscany il Ristorante, Nonna, Casa Nostra
Thousand Oaks $1.0M $539 37 days Made in Italy Bistro, BASTA Restaurant
Newbury Park $950K $485 42 days Sette Sorelle, Spumoni Italian Cafe

Which Italian restaurants offer the most authentic experience?

Authenticity comes from chef ownership, traditional preparations, and imported ingredients. Farfalla Trattoria opened in 2008 under chef and co-owner Santino Coccia, who is originally from Milan. Tuscany il Ristorante has been doing fine Italian dining since 1987, built on fresh seafood and produce, good meat and one of the deeper wine lists in the area. At BASTA in Agoura Hills, everything from the pizza dough to the pasta sauce is made in house with local ingredients. Tuscany sits in the Westlake Plaza and Center, and the garlic knots that arrive before the meal are a local ritual. Casa Nostra Ristorante in Westlake Village leans toward rich, comforting classics and is the place many locals take out-of-town guests. The newest arrival, Sette Sorelle, takes a more modern approach with pastas, pinsas (think pizza on a lighter flatbread crust) and other specialties.

Which Italian restaurants provide the best value?

Value means generous portions, fair prices and a relaxed room. Made in Italy Bistro is the standout here: casual pricing, very large portions and a menu with some range (the grilled colossal prawns with herb and roasted garlic sauce run $45). Buca di Beppo is the straightforward value play, while Tuscany and Casa Nostra are the special occasion end of the spectrum. Maria's Italian Kitchen at 29035 Thousand Oaks Blvd. in Agoura Hills started in the Los Angeles area in 1968 and now has eight locations, so you know what you are getting. The Original Pizza Cookery at 75 West Thousand Oaks Blvd. has been around since 1975 and moved from Woodland Hills to the Conejo Valley in June 2019; it is an easy stop after a morning at Wildwood Regional Park. BASTA, with locations in Whizin Market Square and at 299 E. Thousand Oaks Blvd., is good value for the quality, and the owner is often on the floor talking with guests. Regulars point to the Margarita pizza and Spanish octopus salad. If the plan is dinner and then the game, we have a separate rundown of the best sports bars in the Conejo Valley. Janss Marketplace, at Moorpark Road and Hillcrest Drive in Thousand Oaks, puts shopping and dinner in one stop.

Frequently Asked Questions About Italian Restaurants Conejo Valley

Which Italian restaurants in Thousand Oaks accept reservations?

Tuscany il Ristorante, Casa Nostra and Nonna all take reservations through OpenTable or by phone. On weekends, book ahead if you want a patio or lake view table at Tuscany or Casa Nostra.

What are the price ranges for Italian restaurants in the Conejo Valley?

Nonna and Casa Nostra both list "$30 and under" per person on OpenTable, and Made in Italy Bistro entrees generally land in the $20 to $30 range. Tuscany and the other white tablecloth spots run higher.

Do Italian restaurants in the area offer gluten-free options?

Yes, several do. Made in Italy Bistro gets repeated praise from reviewers for its gluten-free pizza and also offers gluten-free pasta and ciabatta. Most of the established restaurants will accommodate dietary restrictions if you call ahead.

Which neighborhoods offer the best concentration of Italian restaurants?

Westlake Village has the densest cluster of upscale Italian dining, led by Casa Nostra Ristorante and Tuscany il Ristorante. The stretch around Thousand Oaks Boulevard and Janss Marketplace is where the casual options are, and Newbury Park now has both traditional and modern concepts. If you are relocating here, two other guides may be useful: our overview of special education resources in the Conejo Valley and our step by step guide to getting homeowners insurance in the Conejo Valley.

Thinking About Buying or Selling in Thousand Oaks?

Davis Bartels and DB Real Estate Group have closed 500+ transactions in the local market. If a move is on the horizon, our guides to how multiple offers work in the Conejo Valley and ADU investing are a good place to start, and Davis is happy to talk through your situation if that is relevant.

Contact Davis: davisbartels.com