The best pizza in the Conejo Valley is a genuinely competitive question. In a market where Thousand Oaks home prices sit close to $1.0M, families expect good restaurants, and the local pizza scene holds up its end. From a world champion's pies to neighborhood institutions that have fed families for decades, the spots below cover every major style and price point.
Key Takeaways
- Slice House by Tony Gemignani ranks #1 in Conejo Valley pizza, opened July 28, 2023, with large pizzas priced $28-32.
- The Original Pizza Cookery has served Thousand Oaks since 1975, offering the best gluten-free crust in the area at $16-20 per large pizza.
- Toppers Pizza Place has won Best Pizza Category for both East and West Ventura County every year this century across 10 locations.
- Large pizza prices range from $12 to $16 at Fresh Brothers to $28 to $32 at Slice House, with most spots landing in the high teens to low twenties.
- Pizza Nosh operates as the only vegetarian, kosher pizza restaurant in Conejo Valley, located in Agoura Hills with prices $15-19.
Slice House by Tony Gemignani ranks as the best pizza in the Conejo Valley, offering New York, Detroit, Grandma, and Sicilian styles for $28 to $32 per large pizza. Founded by 13-time world champion Tony Gemignani, the Thousand Oaks location opened in July 2023, and the brand was named the 2023 #1 Pizza Brand of the Year by Pizza Marketplace.
Where Can You Find the Best Pizza in the Conejo Valley?
The Conejo Valley's pizza options run from Thousand Oaks, Newbury Park, Westlake Village, Oak Park and Agoura Hills into portions of Calabasas, with pizzerias at every price point. For an area this size, the depth is unusual.
Part of that depth comes down to who lives here. The median Conejo Valley home sold for roughly $1.1 million in late 2025, and that customer base has supported both newer concepts and family-run operations going back generations.
Source: Restaurant menus and local reviews, April 2026
What Makes Slice House by Tony Gemignani Rank #1 in the Conejo Valley?
Slice House by Tony Gemignani pairs a 13-time world pizza champion's recipes with a fast-casual counter. Located at 3297 E Thousand Oaks Blvd, Thousand Oaks, CA 91362, this relative newcomer has quickly become the benchmark for pizza in the Conejo Valley.
Slice House opened in Thousand Oaks on July 28, 2023, the first of a planned multi-unit rollout across the region, with Simi Valley, Woodland Hills, Ventura, Santa Clarita, West Hills and Pasadena among the announced targets. Hours at the time of writing: Sunday through Thursday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., Friday and Saturday 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.
What sets Slice House apart is range done well. The menu covers New York, Detroit, Grandma and Sicilian styles, with some lighter options, plus local craft beer and natural wine. Reviews consistently praise the execution; one customer put it this way: "I'm not exaggerating when I say this is absolutely top five pizzas I've ever had in my life. Depending on which slice you got, it could be a top three contender for sure."
The industry noticed too. Pizza Marketplace named Slice House its 2023 #1 Pizza Brand of the Year, the brand also took the 2023 #1 Top Emerging Brand award, and Tony Gemignani was named the 2023 #1 Top Pizza Executive.
Which Local Pizza Favorites Have Earned Their Place?
Butler's Pizza consistently ranks among locals' top choices. As one regular put it: "Butler's is my favorite pizza spot in Thousand Oaks, bar none." Located at 1655 E Thousand Oaks Blvd, Butler's has built a devoted following on consistency and a crust and sauce that locals rate highly.
The Original Pizza Cookery is the old-school option. It has served pizza, pasta, salads and its signature garlic cheese bread since 1975, and the location at 75 West Thousand Oaks Blvd. is a Thousand Oaks institution. It also has what many consider the best gluten-free crust in the area.
Parma's Pizzeria is the Detroit-style specialist. One reviewer called it "by far the best pizzeria in Thousand Oaks," and the signature pie delivers what the style promises: a thick, crisp crust with cheese pushed to the edges so it caramelizes against the pan. The restaurant describes it as a tribute to the Motor City original.
Toppers Pizza Place is the homegrown success story. Founded by the Jonkers in 1990, it has grown to 10 locations and, by its own count, has won the Best Pizza category for both East and West Ventura County every year this century.
Pizza Nosh, at 3013 Canwood Street in Agoura Hills, is the only vegetarian, kosher pizza place in the Conejo Valley. It is known for friendly service and a vegetarian menu broad enough that non-vegetarians do not feel shortchanged.
How Do Pizza Styles and Prices Compare Across the Valley?
Every major style is represented: New York thin crust, Chicago deep dish, Detroit (rectangular, thick crust, sauce on top) and Sicilian (square cut), along with the usual California variations.
| Restaurant | Style | Large Pizza Price | Specialty | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slice House | Multi-style | $28-32 | Championship pizza | Thousand Oaks |
| Butler's Pizza | Traditional | $22-26 | Thin crust | Thousand Oaks |
| Toppers Pizza | California | $20-24 | Award-winning | Thousand Oaks |
| Pizza Cookery | Traditional | $16-20 | Garlic rolls | Thousand Oaks |
| Parma's Pizzeria | Detroit | $18-22 | Square pies | Agoura Hills |
| Ameci Pizza | Italian | $14-18 | Family recipes | Newbury Park |
| Fresh Brothers | Health-conscious | $12-16 | Organic ingredients | Westlake Village |
| Pizza Nosh | Kosher/Vegetarian | $15-19 | Plant-based | Agoura Hills |
Prices track ingredient quality more than anything, though the customer base helps. Thousand Oaks home values average close to $1 million, which gives restaurants room to invest in better ingredients and staff.
Purists, vegetarians and the gluten-averse are all covered, from foldable New York slices to thick, crunchy Detroit squares.
Dietary restrictions are easy to work around here. Several spots carry Udi's gluten-free crust, and Fresh Brothers offers original, skinny, cauliflower, deep dish, gluten-free and keto crusts.
Pizza is one piece of the picture. This blog also ranks the best Mexican food in the Conejo Valley and the local coffee shops, and for families weighing a move, the guides to Conejo Valley high schools and youth sports programs cover the rest.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza in the Conejo Valley
What are the operating hours for the top pizza places in Thousand Oaks?
Hours are similar across the top spots. Slice House runs Sunday through Thursday 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. and Friday and Saturday 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. The Original Pizza Cookery and Butler's Pizza typically close around 9 p.m. on weekdays and 10 p.m. on weekends. Hours change, so check before you go, especially on holidays.
Which pizza restaurants offer the best gluten-free options?
The Original Pizza Cookery gets the most credit for its gluten-free crust, and Fresh Brothers builds gluten-free into a broader health-conscious menu. Pizza Hut locations carry Udi's gluten-free crust, and many local spots, including Slice House, offer a gluten-free option.
How do pizza prices in the Conejo Valley compare to Los Angeles?
Large pizzas in the Conejo Valley run roughly $12 to $32, in line with West LA pricing. What stands out is the spread: one premium pizzeria at the top and a deep bench of family-priced spots in the teens, all within a short drive.
What makes Slice House different from other pizza chains?
Slice House by Tony Gemignani, founded by the 13-time world pizza champion, serves New York, Detroit, Grandma and Sicilian style pizzas under one roof. Unlike most chains, each style gets its own dough, sauce and technique. Pizza Marketplace named it the 2023 #1 Pizza Brand of the Year.
Thinking About Buying or Selling in Thousand Oaks?
Davis Bartels and the DB Real Estate Group have closed 500+ transactions across the Conejo Valley, Ventura County and west Los Angeles since 2009. If a move is somewhere on your horizon, happy to talk through the market and your options, no pressure either way.
Contact Davis: davisbartels.com
