In This Article
- Where Can You Find the Best Pizza in the Conejo Valley?
- What Makes Slice House by Tony Gemignani Rank #1 in the Conejo Valley?
- Which Local Pizza Favorites Have Earned Their Place?
- How Do Pizza Styles and Prices Compare Across the Valley?
- Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza in the Conejo Valley
When you're searching for the best pizza Conejo Valley has to offer, you're looking at one of California's most competitive pizza scenes. With home prices averaging $994,477 to $1.0M across Thousand Oaks , families here expect exceptional dining options, and the local pizza scene delivers. From award-winning championship pies to neighborhood institutions serving families for decades, these 15 spots represent every style, price point, and craving you could imagine.
Where Can You Find the Best Pizza in the Conejo Valley?
The Conejo Valley's pizza landscape spans from Thousand Oaks, Newbury Park, Westlake Village, Oak Park, Agoura Hills and portions of Calabasas , creating a diverse collection of pizzerias that cater to every taste and budget. With dozens of fantastic pizza joints, Conejo Valley is one of the best places for pizza lovers in Southern California.
The concentration of top-tier pizzerias reflects the area's demographics and dining expectations. The median price of a Conejo Valley home was $1,116,250 in November 2025, up 2.9% from last November , indicating a community that values quality dining experiences. This economic foundation has supported both innovative newcomers and established family-run operations that have served the community for generations.
$8$12$16$20$24$28$32Slice House$30Butler's$24Toppers$22Pizza Cookery$18Ameci$16Fresh Bros$12Average Large Pizza PricePrice ($)
Source: Restaurant menus and local reviews, April 2026
What Makes Slice House by Tony Gemignani Rank #1 in the Conejo Valley?
Slice House by Tony Gemignani, founded by the globally acclaimed 13-time world pizza champion, offers an unparalleled pizza experience, blending artisan craftsmanship with fast-casual dining. Located at 3297 E Thousand Oaks Blvd, Thousand Oaks, CA 91362 , this relative newcomer has quickly established itself as the gold standard for pizza in the Conejo Valley.
Slice House opened in Thousand Oaks on July 28, 2023 , representing the first in a multi-unit deal, with plans to open more across the Los Angeles area from Simi Valley to Woodland Hills, Ventura, Santa Clarita, West Hills, and Pasadena. The restaurant operates Sundays through Thursdays 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. and Fridays & Saturdays 11 a.m. to 10 p.m.
What sets Slice House apart is its authentic variety. Slice House provides a diverse menu from signature New York, Detroit, Grandma, and Sicilian style pizzas, including health-conscious options, complemented by a hand-picked selection of local craft brews and natural wines. Customer reviews consistently praise the execution: "I'm not exaggerating when I say this is absolutely top five pizzas I've ever had in my life. Depending on which slice you got, it could be a top three contender for sure."
The national recognition speaks volumes. Slice House was named the #1 Pizza Brand of the Year by Pizza Marketplace, while Tony Gemignani was named the 2023 #1 Top Pizza Executive and Slice House was named the 2023 #1 Top Emerging Brand.
Which Local Pizza Favorites Have Earned Their Place?
Butler's Pizza consistently ranks among locals' top choices. "Butler's is my favorite pizza spot in Thousand Oaks, bar none." Located at 1655 E Thousand Oaks Blvd , Butler's has built a devoted following through consistent quality and crust and sauce that are very good.
The Original Pizza Cookery represents old-school California pizza tradition. The Original Pizza Cookery has been serving up delicious pizzas, pastas, salads and warm homemade garlic cheese bread to happy customers since opening their doors in 1975. Located at 75 West Thousand Oaks Blvd., Thousand Oaks , this institution offers the best gluten-free crust in the area.
Parma's Pizzeria brings Detroit-style excellence to the valley. Customer reviews highlight the quality: "Parma is by far the best pizzeria in Thousand Oaks!" The restaurant specializes in Detroit-style pizza with its thick, crispy crust and cheese stretching to the edges, creating a deliciously caramelized border. At Parma's, we craft our Detroit-style pizza as a tribute to Motor City's iconic recipe.
Toppers Pizza Place deserves recognition as a local success story. Toppers Pizza Place has been winner of Best Pizza Category for both East and West Ventura County Every Year this Century! Toppers is a Ventura County based success story, founded by the Jonkers in 1990 and growing to 10 locations.
For those seeking unique options, Pizza Nosh is the only vegetarian, kosher pizza place in the Conejo Valley , located at 3013 Canwood Street, Agoura Hills. Pizza Nosh is known for its friendly service and a great vegetarian menu (in addition to plenty of selections for meat-eaters).
How Do Pizza Styles and Prices Compare Across the Valley?
The Conejo Valley offers every major pizza style, from traditional to innovative. Other varieties of pizza include New York thin-crust style, Chicago style (deep dish, thick crust), Detroit style (rectangular, thick crust, sauce on top) and Sicilian (square cut) and others.
| Restaurant | Style | Large Pizza Price | Specialty | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Slice House | Multi-style | $28-32 | Championship pizza | Thousand Oaks |
| Butler's Pizza | Traditional | $22-26 | Thin crust | Thousand Oaks |
| Toppers Pizza | California | $20-24 | Award-winning | Thousand Oaks |
| Pizza Cookery | Traditional | $16-20 | Garlic rolls | Thousand Oaks |
| Parma's Pizzeria | Detroit | $18-22 | Square pies | Agoura Hills |
| Ameci Pizza | Italian | $14-18 | Family recipes | Newbury Park |
| Fresh Brothers | Health-conscious | $12-16 | Organic ingredients | Westlake Village |
| Pizza Nosh | Kosher/Vegetarian | $15-19 | Plant-based | Agoura Hills |
Price points reflect both ingredient quality and local demographics. Homes in Thousand Oaks sell after 44 days on the market, with average values of $994,477 , supporting restaurants that invest in premium ingredients and experienced staff.
The variety ensures every preference is covered. Pizza purists, vegetarians and foodies can likely agree that Conejo Valley has plenty of pizza for everyone. Whether you're craving New York-style pizza famous for its thin, foldable crust or Detroit-style pizza with thick, crunchy crust with cheese edges , the valley delivers.
Many establishments cater to dietary restrictions. Various options include Udi's Gluten-Free Crust , while Fresh Brothers offers traditional pizzas on various crusts including original, skinny, cauliflower, deep dish, gluten-free and keto.
Beyond pizza, the area offers excellent dining throughout every category, from best Mexican food in the Conejo Valley to great coffee shops, making it a true foodie destination. Families appreciate these options alongside top-ranked schools and youth sports programs that make the valley an ideal place to call home.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza in the Conejo Valley
What are the operating hours for the top pizza places in Thousand Oaks?
Most pizza places operate similar hours, with Slice House open Monday through Thursday 11:00 am to 9:00 pm, Friday and Saturday 11:00 am to 10:00 pm, and Sunday 11:00 am to 9:00 pm. The Original Pizza Cookery and Butler's Pizza typically close around 9 pm on weekdays and 10 pm on weekends. Always call ahead on holidays as hours may vary.
Which pizza restaurants offer the best gluten-free options?
The Original Pizza Cookery has the best gluten-free crust in the area , while Fresh Brothers offers gluten-free crusts alongside their health-conscious menu. Pizza Hut locations offer Udi's Gluten-Free Crust , and many local spots including Slice House provide gluten-free options.
How do pizza prices in the Conejo Valley compare to Los Angeles?
Conejo Valley pizza prices range from $12-32 for large pizzas, which is competitive with West LA pricing but offers better value. With median home prices of $1,116,250 , the area supports premium pizzerias while maintaining family-friendly options. The quality-to-price ratio often exceeds what you'll find closer to downtown LA.
What makes Slice House different from other pizza chains?
Slice House by Tony Gemignani, founded by the globally acclaimed 13-time world pizza champion , offers signature New York, Detroit, Grandma, and Sicilian style pizzas in one location. Unlike typical chains, each pizza style uses different doughs, sauces, and techniques perfected by a world champion pizzaiolo. Slice House was named the #1 Pizza Brand of the Year by industry experts.
Thinking About Buying or Selling in Thousand Oaks?
Davis Bartels and the DB Real Estate Group have helped nearly 1,000 families navigate the local market since 2009. Whether you're exploring your options or ready to make a move, reach out for a no-pressure conversation about your goals.
Contact Davis: davisbartels.com
