Lake Sherwood homes sold at a median price of $2.2M in March 2026, down 35.6% from a year earlier, yet this gated community around Sherwood Country Club remains one of Southern California's most sought after addresses. With 34 homes sold over the trailing 12 months and Rick Caruso's February 2026 purchase of the Sherwood Lake Club still fresh, the picture is more mixed than a single headline number suggests, for buyers and sellers alike.

Key Takeaways

  • Lake Sherwood homes sold at a median price of $2.2 million in March 2026, down 35.6% from the previous year.
  • Buyers need a minimum annual income of $556,000 to afford the median priced Lake Sherwood home using the 28% debt ratio rule.
  • Lake Sherwood's $2.57 million median falls between Calabasas at $1.4 million and Hidden Hills at $9.22 million, based on recent figures from different sources and months.
  • Rick Caruso acquired the Sherwood Lake Club in February 2026, with reported plans for a Miramar Club style property.
  • Homes in Lake Sherwood typically sell after 49 to 60 days on market with a median price per square foot of $743.
Quick Answer

Lake Sherwood homes had a median sale price of $2.2 million as of March 2026, down 35.6% year over year, with a median price per square foot of $743. Buyers typically need a minimum annual income of $556,000 to qualify. Homes sell in 49 to 60 days depending on the data source, and a second source puts the median at $2.575 million.

What Are Current Lake Sherwood Home Prices in 2026?

Pricing data for Lake Sherwood varies by source and timeframe, which is normal for a community with only a few dozen sales a year. One source puts the median home price in Lake Sherwood at $2,575,000, while the most recent month's sales came in at $2.2M. On the listing side, in March 2026 Lake Sherwood homes were listed at a median of $2.67M, ranging from $2,149,000 to $8,699,000.

Price per square foot tells a similar story. The median sale price per square foot is $743, down 39.8% from a year earlier, while current listings ask a median of $821 per square foot. Most homes trade between $2 million and $6 million, with the premier estates exceeding $10 million.

Lake Sherwood Median Home Prices 2026 $3M $2.5M $2M $1.5M $1M Lake Sherwood $2.57M Calabasas $1.4M Hidden Hills $9.22M Westlake Village $900K

Source: Multiple MLS sources, March 2026

How Has the Lake Sherwood Market Performed This Year?

Lake Sherwood has seen notable shifts in 2026. The market is somewhat competitive by luxury standards: one source has homes selling in 60 days, another puts the average at 49 days. Either way, expect a measured pace rather than a bidding war.

Inventory is small in absolute terms, though not necessarily tight relative to sales. Recent data shows 23 listed homes with an average of 99 days on market and a median list price of $4,450,000. Against 34 sales in the past 12 months, that is several months of supply, and the gap between the $4.45M median list price and the $2.2M median sale price says a lot about where sellers and buyers currently disagree. The community itself is only about 660 residences, made up of a guard-gated golf club community, three electronically gated communities, and lake view homes along Lake Sherwood Drive.

The wild card is Rick Caruso's purchase of the Sherwood Lake Club in February 2026 through an LLC, with reported plans for a Miramar Club style property along the lines of Montecito's Rosewood hotel. Nothing is built yet and plans can change, but a high profile owner investing in the lake tends to support buyer confidence in a market that already has limited housing stock and strong lifestyle appeal. If you are weighing how to sell your home in Lake Sherwood, timing around this news is worth a conversation.

How Much Income Do You Need to Buy in Lake Sherwood?

Here is the math on the $2,575,000 median. With a 20% down payment of $515,000 and a 30-year fixed mortgage at an interest rate of 6.46% (the rate at the time of writing), estimated principal and interest comes to $12,970 a month. Using the 28% rule, you would need to earn at least $556K a year, before accounting for property taxes, insurance and any HOA dues.

A second source, using different assumptions, lands lower: in March 2026, with 25% down you would need about $14.2K a month to cover expenses, and if that is 35% of your gross monthly income, roughly $489K a year gets you into the median priced home. The spread between $489K and $556K comes down to down payment and debt ratio assumptions, so treat both as rough guides and run your own numbers with a lender. The table below scales the 20% down, 28% rule version up to the higher price points.

Home Price Down Payment (20%) Monthly Payment* Required Income
$2.575M (Median) $515,000 $12,970 $556,000
$4.0M $800,000 $20,752 $889,000
$6.0M $1,200,000 $31,128 $1,334,000
$10.0M $2,000,000 $51,880 $2,223,000

*Estimated principal and interest only, 30-year fixed at 6.46%. Property taxes, insurance and HOA dues are additional.

How Does Lake Sherwood Compare to Hidden Hills and Calabasas?

Lake Sherwood is an unincorporated community in the Santa Monica Mountains and is widely considered the most exclusive address in the Conejo Valley. The closest comparisons buyers make are Hidden Hills and Calabasas, and the three sit at very different price points.

Hidden Hills commands the highest prices of the three. In November 2025, Hidden Hills homes were listed at a median of $9.22M; with 25% down you would need about $49.1K a month to cover expenses and roughly $1.68M a year in income. Prices run from $5 million to well into the $20 million range in this gated equestrian community. We break the two down side by side in Hidden Hills vs Lake Sherwood.

Calabasas is the more accessible of the three, with homes ranging from $800,000 to $3 million and a median around $1.4 million. Houses in Classic Calabasas typically sell for $1.2 to $2.2 million, well below both Lake Sherwood and Hidden Hills.

Closer to home, Westlake Village luxury buyers often weigh Lake Sherwood against North Ranch and Westlake Island. If North Ranch is in the running, see North Ranch vs Lake Sherwood.

One distinction worth knowing: Hidden Hills and Calabasas are served by the Las Virgenes Unified School District, which bills itself as a "Destination School District" and points to strong test scores, placements at top universities and small class sizes. Lake Sherwood falls under Conejo Valley Unified, covered below. Both districts are well regarded, but they are not the same district.

What Amenities and Lifestyle Does Lake Sherwood Offer?

Life here centers on two things: Sherwood Country Club and the lake. The club is private and member owned, set at the base of the Santa Monica Mountains, with an 18-hole Jack Nicklaus signature course, a driving range and a Georgian style clubhouse.

The facilities go well beyond golf: 12 tennis courts (8 hard, one with stadium seating, two clay and two grass), all lit for night play, plus a sand volleyball court, swimming pool, gymnasium, fitness center, dining room and pub, locker rooms and a full service spa.

The lake is the rarer asset. It is a body contact lake, so swimming, fishing, paddleboarding and boating are all allowed. Originally called Potrero Lake, it was built in 1904, covers roughly 165 acres, and is often described as the oldest man-made lake in California.

Inside the gates, the Sherwood Lake Club's Grille offers indoor dining, a lounge and a covered terrace, serving lunch and dinner Wednesday through Sunday for members and their guests. Hours and offerings may change under the new Caruso ownership, so check before you plan around them.

Beyond the gates, Mastro's Steakhouse in Thousand Oaks, an OpenTable Diners' Choice winner for 2025, sits near Gardens of the World and the Civic Arts Plaza. The Stonehaus in Westlake Village is the local default for coffee, wine and pastries in a vineyard setting.

Lake Sherwood students attend Westlake High School, which carries a Niche grade of A+ and a GreatSchools rating of 10 out of 10, and Westlake Elementary School, with a Niche grade of A and a GreatSchools rating of 8 out of 10.

Frequently Asked Questions About Lake Sherwood Homes

Is Lake Sherwood a good investment in 2026?

The case for Lake Sherwood rests on scarcity (roughly 660 residences), the lake and club lifestyle, and the Caruso acquisition as a possible future tailwind. With only a few dozen sales a year, a median swing like the 35.6% drop over the past year often says more about which homes happened to sell than about underlying values. The fundamentals are supportive for a long hold, but no one should treat appreciation as guaranteed, and the right answer depends on your timeline and the specific property.

Can you buy a Lake Sherwood home without country club membership?

Yes. Home ownership and club membership are entirely separate. Buying a home does not include membership in Sherwood Country Club or any right to use the club's facilities. Membership runs to approximately 375 golf members and is by invitation or member referral, so if the club is part of the appeal, start that conversation early.

What are the HOA fees and restrictions in Lake Sherwood?

There is no single answer, because Lake Sherwood is really several associations: a guard-gated golf club community, three electronically gated communities, and lake view homes along Lake Sherwood Drive, each with its own dues, architectural standards and rules. Dues vary by gate, so confirm the current HOA budget, CC&Rs and any pending assessments on the specific property during your due diligence.

How does Lake Sherwood compare to other luxury communities?

Lake Sherwood holds up well on schools. Students attend Westlake High School, a Conejo Valley Unified public school with a total enrollment of about 2,280 and a student to teacher ratio of 24:1, with a reported 99% graduation rate and average SAT score of 1350.

Thinking About Buying or Selling in Lake Sherwood?

Davis Bartels and the DB Real Estate Group have closed 500+ transactions in the area. If Lake Sherwood is on your list, or you own there and are weighing a sale, happy to walk through the numbers for your situation.

Contact Davis: davisbartels.com