Quick Answer

Old Agoura is where Agoura Hills still smells like hay and sage. It is the city's original settlement, a loose grid of custom homes, ranch houses and horse properties on large parcels, with corrals in the yard, no HOA, and Cheeseboro Canyon a short ride away. It offers land, room for animals and quiet minutes from the 101, and homes run about $1.1M to $4.6M and up, with typical sales landing around $2.3M.

On a weekend morning in Old Agoura you will pass a rider walking her horse down Colodny Drive toward the arena at Old Agoura Park, hear a rooster somewhere behind a fence, and watch mountain bikers roll past on their way into Cheeseboro Canyon. This is the land the Colodny brothers subdivided in 1924 and marketed as a place to raise chickens and rabbits, and a century later the neighborhood has never let go of that idea. There are no model homes here. A purchase here is a piece of ground, a way of living, and a community that has fought hard to keep it that way.

Old Agoura at a glance
HomesAbout 370 custom homes, ranch houses and horse properties
Built1930s to present, owner built and custom, no production builder
Price rangeAbout $1.1M to $4.6M and up
HOANone. A voluntary homeowners group with no mandatory dues
GatedNo. Some individual properties have their own gates
LotsLarger parcels, often an acre or more, horse keeping on many of them
SchoolsLas Virgenes Unified, Agoura High nearby
Getting aroundCar dependent, direct access to the 101 at the Chesebro exit

Hay, Horses and the Trailhead at the End of the Street

Daily life in Old Agoura is organized around dirt. Horse trails thread through the neighborhood and feed into Old Agoura Park on Chesebro Road, which locals simply call the Horse Park. The city runs a public equestrian arena there, along with a ballfield, a playground, restrooms and a perimeter path that walkers and riders share. Residents pushed for that park for years and finally saw it open in 1995, and it remains the social center of the neighborhood.

Step past the park and you are in roughly 4,000 acres of Cheeseboro and Palo Comado Canyon, with Upper Las Virgenes Canyon beyond that. Hikers, cyclists, riders and dog walkers all use it, and that back door to open space is a central part of the appeal. Malibu Creek State Park, King Gillette Ranch and Sage Ranch are a short drive away. The area was once nicknamed Picture City for its proximity to the Paramount Movie Ranch, and the hills still look the part.

What you give up is walkability. Almost nothing is on foot. Groceries and coffee mean a drive to Agoura Gateway, Twin Oaks or Roadside Plaza. The trade is that the 101 is right there at the Chesebro exit, so commuting toward Calabasas and the Valley or west to Westlake Village is as easy as anywhere in the city.

The Homes: Stone Cottages, Ranch Houses and New Estates on Acreage

There is no production builder, no floor plan sheet and no two houses alike. Old Agoura grew one parcel at a time, so a ranch house with a corral sits a few doors from a stone cottage, a modern farmhouse remodel and a 6,000 square foot estate finished in the last decade. Many homes we show here fall between about 2,000 and 6,000 square feet on larger parcels, and raw land still comes up for sale for buyers who want to build their own.

Many properties keep horses on site with private corrals, tack rooms and turnouts, and the larger parcels often have pools, workshops and oversized garages. Many homes are on septic rather than sewer, which is normal for a neighborhood this old, and it varies lot by lot.

Pricing reflects the land. Homes run about $1.1M to $4.6M and up, with a recent median sale around $2.3M. On a per square foot basis Old Agoura trades at roughly $930, against about $550 for Agoura Hills as a whole, which is the acreage and equestrian premium showing up plainly. Homes also take longer to sell, averaging around 115 days versus about 44 citywide, because the buyer pool for a horse property is narrower and pickier. For sellers that means pricing with discipline from day one. For buyers it means there is usually room to negotiate. We keep current numbers on our Agoura Hills home values page.

Schools: Las Virgenes Unified, With Agoura High Close By

Old Agoura is served by the Las Virgenes Unified School District, which covers Agoura Hills, Calabasas, Hidden Hills and most of Westlake Village. Agoura High School on Driver Avenue is the nearest high school and the district's largest, with about 1,700 students. Sumac Elementary on Calmfield Avenue is one of the district elementary schools serving this part of Agoura Hills.

District boundaries in this part of Agoura Hills are drawn at the street level, and the east and west sides of the neighborhood can map differently. Before you write an offer, run the specific address through the district's own lookup. We do this for every client here as a matter of course.

A Neighborhood That Organizes

There is no mandatory homeowners association in Old Agoura, no CC&R assessments and no dues. What exists instead is a voluntary, nonprofit homeowners group that has been active since the 1980s and asks for contributions to cover insurance, communications and the occasional legal fight. Roughly 150 households belong, and the group meets monthly on planning, building and safety issues.

That matters because this neighborhood has spent decades defending its rural zoning. Residents beat back a 1967 county effort to repeal farm animal zoning, killed a 1995 proposal for a go-kart and arcade amusement park on Canwood Street, and more recently have been fighting a townhome project proposed near Chesebro Road and Palo Comado. Development pressure at the edges is a constant. Buyers who value the character here should expect to be asked to show up for it, and should check current city planning agendas for anything near their block. For context on how Old Agoura compares to the city's other pockets, see our guide to Agoura Hills neighborhoods.

What to know before you write an offer

Old Agoura offers acreage, room for animals and privacy, and owners maintain all three themselves. Many parcels have room for horses, a workshop or a second structure, and many houses have history rather than tract origins. There is no gate, no pool club, no lake and no HOA to handle the landscaping. Lake and golf access are at Lake Lindero on the other side of the city, not here.

  • Septic versus sewer. Confirm for the specific parcel and budget for a septic inspection and any required upgrades.
  • Animal rights. Horse and livestock allowances depend on the zoning of each lot. Verify before assuming you can add stalls.
  • Trail access. Being near a trail is not the same as having a legal easement to ride out. Check recorded easements.
  • Fire and insurance. This is canyon-adjacent wildland interface. Get insurance quotes early in escrow, not at the end.
  • No HOA services. Road upkeep beyond city streets, fencing and drainage are on you.

Buyers who like the idea of larger lots but want something more finished often cross-shop Medea Valley Estates. Those who decide they want a classic suburban street usually end up in Oakcreek Village or Hillrise instead. Old Agoura rewards the buyer who knows exactly why they are here.

Owning in Old Agoura

What a typical home costs to own

About $13,454/month plus property tax

  • Principal and interest$13,454
  • Property tax (Los Angeles County)Not included
  • HOANone

Estimate for a $2.5M home, near the middle of the recent range here, with 20% down at 7.11% (30 year fixed, Freddie Mac, November 12, 2026). Homeowners insurance is extra and varies with fire zone, so get a quote early. Your lender's figures will differ.

Agoura Hills market, latest data

  • Median sale price$1.32M
  • Change over 12 months+10.6%
  • Typical days on market65

Citywide, Redfin, three months ending October 2026. Agoura Hills home values

Our experience here

Davis Bartels

We have sold homes in Old Agoura and work in the neighborhood regularly. We are glad to share what we are seeing on the ground.

Get a private valuation (805) 341-6125

Agoura Hills home prices, the last five years

Agoura Hills typical home value by year. Source: Zillow Research, Zillow Home Value Index, through September 2026.
MonthTypical home value
September 2022$1,177,941
September 2023$1,172,717
September 2024$1,231,330
September 2025$1,204,083
September 2026$1,221,554

Questions people ask about Old Agoura

Is Old Agoura a gated community?

No. Old Agoura is an open, historic neighborhood with public streets and no community gate. Some larger estates have their own driveway gates and perimeter fencing, but that is property by property. There is also no mandatory HOA, so there are no shared private roads or common areas to gate off.

Can you keep horses in Old Agoura?

Yes, and that is the point of the neighborhood. Many properties have private corrals and horse facilities, horse trails run through the neighborhood, and Old Agoura Park has a public equestrian arena. Animal allowances depend on each lot's zoning, so confirm the specific parcel before counting on a particular number of horses.

Does Old Agoura have an HOA?

There is no mandatory HOA and no dues. A voluntary, nonprofit homeowners group has represented the neighborhood since the 1980s and asks for contributions to cover insurance, communications and occasional legal costs. Roughly 150 households belong. Because it is voluntary, it provides advocacy rather than services like landscaping or road maintenance.

What do homes cost in Old Agoura?

Homes run about $1.1M to $4.6M and up, with a recent median sale around $2.3M. Expect roughly $930 per square foot, well above the Agoura Hills average, because you are paying for acreage and horse facilities. Buildable lots also trade, recently at a median asking price near $2.2M.

What schools serve Old Agoura?

Old Agoura is in the Las Virgenes Unified School District. Agoura High School on Driver Avenue is the nearest high school, and Sumac Elementary is one of the district elementary schools in this part of Agoura Hills. Boundaries are drawn street by street here, so verify the exact address with the district before buying.

Are Old Agoura homes on septic or sewer?

Both. Many of the older parcels are on septic systems, while some homes, including at least one near Old Agoura Park, are connected to sewer. It varies lot by lot. Confirm which applies to the specific property, order a septic inspection during escrow, and budget for any upgrades the county may require.

Thinking about Old Agoura?

Whether you are weighing a move here or wondering what your home would bring, Davis and the team are happy to talk it through, street by street. No obligation.

Request a private valuation or call (805) 341-6125.

Sources
  1. City of Agoura Hills, Old Agoura Park
  2. City of Agoura Hills, Parks and Facilities
  3. Old Agoura Homeowners
  4. Old Agoura Homeowners, Historical Challenges
  5. The Acorn, Update on Old Agoura Homes
  6. The Acorn, History of Agoura Hills
  7. RubyHome, Old Agoura
  8. Redfin, Old Agoura Housing Market
  9. Las Virgenes Unified School District

Facts checked October 2026.